Fall to Festive: How to Start Holiday Decorating in September (Without Looking Crazy)

Fall to Festive: How to Start Holiday Decorating in September (Without Looking Crazy)

If you’ve ever been tempted to pull out your Christmas bins in September but stopped yourself because you worried the neighbors might think you’ve lost it—this blog is for you!

You’re not alone, friend. There’s something about the crisp air, the golden leaves, and that little tingle of excitement that whispers: the holidays are coming.

For many of us, fall and Christmas are our favorite times of the year. Autumn feels like a warm hug—pumpkin spice, cozy blankets, and evenings that beg for candles. Then there’s Christmas, with its sparkling lights, joyful music, and the hope of Emmanuel.

The challenge? How do we blend the two so we can start decorating early, enjoy the cozy vibes for longer, and still have a natural transition when Thanksgiving ends and the Christmas season officially begins?

The good news is—you can! With a few thoughtful choices, you can create a home that feels both autumnal and festive starting in September, and then simply layer in Christmas magic as December approaches. Let’s talk about how to make it happen.

Why Start Holiday Decorating in September?

For some of us, decorating early is about joy. Studies even show that holiday decorating can boost your mood and reduce stress. Why wouldn’t we want an extra month or two of twinkle lights and cozy corners?

There’s also practicality. Decorating early means:

  • You can spread out your budget, buying a little at a time instead of all at once.

  • You can enjoy your décor longer—after all, what’s the point of hauling out boxes for only three weeks in December?

  • You avoid the stress of trying to decorate everything in one weekend.

Most importantly, you’re creating a warm and welcoming space for yourself and your loved ones. As Ecclesiastes reminds us, “To everything there is a season…” Why not stretch out the season of joy just a little longer?

Start with a Cozy Fall Base

Think of September as your chance to set the stage. This is your foundation—a warm, autumn-inspired backdrop that will make layering Christmas touches effortless later.

Textures & Layers

Color Palette Idea 1: Classic Autumn Warmth

  • Rust, burnt orange, golden yellow, deep brown

  • Cozy farmhouse vibe, pairs well with pumpkins and harvest décor

Color Palette Idea 2: Neutral & Nature-Inspired

  • Cream, beige, sage green, warm gray

  • Soothing and timeless—perfect for blending with Christmas greenery later

Add Subtle Holiday Hints

This is where the magic begins. Without screaming “Merry Christmas” in September, you can start weaving in pieces that will carry into December.

  • Evergreen Touches: Add a cedar garland to your mantel or staircase with wisps of pampas grass and autumn leaves tucked in. I am also loving this real-touch evergreen tree! It's small and natural looking—giving off more of a potted plant vibe this time of year, rather than a full-blown Christmas tree. Check it out —> HERE!

  • Neutral Pumpkins: Instead of bright orange, use white, cream, or metallic pumpkins that won’t clash with holiday accents later. Experiment with these handcrafted, knit pumpkins in neutral tones for a soft, gentle look.

  • Metallic Hints: Introduce bronze, copper, or gold candleholders in fall. I love these modern gold taper candle holders that come in a set of six for under $21. Check them out —> here. The rich gold blends seamlessly with most decorating styles. Later, you can mix in silver candle holders to add a touch of Christmas sparkle. Don't forget to add some battery-operated ivory taper candles like the ones I found on Amazon —> check them out!

  • Scented Candles: Cedar, pine, or cinnamon-vanilla scents can work for both fall and holiday seasons.

Pro Tip: Try mixing pinecones with mini pumpkins in the same bowl or tray. It looks festive but neutral enough to glide into November and December.

Transition Décor by Thanksgiving

When November rolls around, you can begin shifting your décor from fall to holiday without doing a total overhaul. Think of it as swapping, not starting over.

  • Edit Out the Fall-Specific Items: Put away turkeys, “Happy Harvest” signs, and anything that screams only autumn.

  • Keep the Cozy Base: Plaids, greenery, candles, and baskets stay.

  • Add Wintery Touches: String lights, plaid ribbons, pinecones, and birch logs. These are timeless and work equally well in late fall and Christmas. I like tucking battery-operated fairy lights in places where outlets aren't handy and extension cords look out of place—like in plants, vases, jars, woven throughout the bookshelf in my living room. These (click here) are fairy lights I've purchased in the past and have been very happy with the quality and how long the batteries last.

Color Palette Idea 3: Rustic Woodland

  • Deep green, cream, natural wood, pops of red

  • Perfect if you love the cabin-in-the-woods vibe

Color Palette Idea 4: Elegant Minimalist

  • White, cream, metallics, evergreen

  • Sleek and simple, works beautifully for smaller spaces or modern homes

Go Full Holiday Magic After Thanksgiving

The day after Thanksgiving is your green light for all things Christmas. But because you’ve already laid the groundwork, you won’t feel overwhelmed.

  • Swap Pumpkins for Ornaments: If you’ve been using neutral pumpkins in your décor bowls, simply switch them out for shiny ornaments.

  • Add a Christmas Tree: It will feel natural against the greenery and cozy layers you’ve had out since September.

  • Layer Sparkle: Add twinkle lights, garlands, and ornaments to your existing décor without starting from scratch.

Tips for Blending Fall & Christmas Décor Seamlessly

  • Pick a Consistent Palette: Stick to two or three core colors across both seasons so everything flows together.

  • Choose Multi-Season Items: Pinecones, birch logs, greenery, and candles work for both.

  • Think Storage-Friendly: Use items that can transition instead of buying double the décor.

  • Stay True to Your Style: Farmhouse cozy, modern minimalist, boho chic—there’s no wrong way if it makes your home feel like you.

And don’t be afraid to let your faith shine in your décor, too. Scripture art, nativity sets, or simply keeping a spirit of gratitude in your home atmosphere reminds everyone of the true reason for this season.

Wrapping It Up

Friend, decorating for Christmas early doesn’t make you “crazy.” It makes you someone who loves beauty, coziness, and joy. By blending autumn warmth with Christmas sparkle, you get to enjoy the best of both worlds—and you’ll find the transition from September to December feels natural and stress-free.

Start small this year. Add a cozy blanket, a neutral pumpkin, a strand of fairy lights. Let your home become a reflection of the peace and joy you carry in your heart. And remember—whether it’s pumpkins or pinecones, twinkle lights or garlands—it’s all about creating a space where love and faith flourish.

May your home be cozy, your season be bright, and your heart be filled with gratitude. Happy Fall-Mas!

Back to blog